Who cares about Afghanistan?

You can’t get anything accomplished if no one gives a damn.

Matthieu Aikens’ ‘Last Tango in Kabul,’ which appeared 18 August in Rolling Stone, is a fascinating and well-written article. I read it eagerly, and it reminded me of other pieces-fiction and non-fiction-that I have read on Afghanistan. The country shouldn’t be interesting, from a tourist standpoint: it’s poor,  unsafe, it has little in the way of arts, architecture, music and the like. But yet I’d still love to visit it and, if I had a little more nerve and a free-for-all attitude, I’d love to have been in Kabul for what Aiken’s describes as the ‘Kabubble,’ when expats post-9/11 were making easier money and “laissant le bon temps rouler” despite the shambles the country was in.
Yet although the piece reads like a novel, at the end of it I felt ultimately…ashamed. Aikens points this out in his article, the fact that these expats cared more about getting rich than doing what they were supposed to do: helping Afghanistan. It would certainly seem like they failed at their mission, since Afghanistan is hardly a thriving democracy nor is it any safer; in fact, one of the stresses of Aikens’ article is that its more unsafe than it was in the past, at least for foreigners.
“As we’re learning in Iraq, invading a country is much easier than leaving it behind.”
America invaded Afghanistan because it wanted to destroy the Taliban, which was responsible for the 9/11 Attacks. America wanted to find Osama bin Laden, the mastermind behind the attacks. The latter was accomplished nearly 10 years after 9/11; the former, well….if the catapulting rise of the Islamic State–or Da’ish– in Iraq and Syria is any indication, it doesn’t take much for extremists to pop up or return. Perhaps the Taliban was squashed for a while during America’s takeover of Afghanistan, but that doesn’t mean that ‘former members’ weren’t feeling the same ideologies as before just because they were biding their time.
Sourced from Opinion-maker.org
Did we?
The problem with Afghanistan was that the US had concrete goals: find Osama. Stop the Taliban. These goals didn’t have anything to do with the ordinary people, or day-to-day living. Afghanistan is poor; Afghanistan needs development. Sure, former FLOTUS Laura Bush said we were invading to help Afghani women. Well, in order to help Afghani women, we have to help-and influence-Afghan men first. This is a task that takes time; developping Afghanistan takes time. I’m sure some of the expats living in Kabul meant well; I hope they tried their best. But, ultimately, if the Americans didn’t really care about making lasting change, and most Afghans were either pro-Taliban/anti-West or wary, then there will be no positive change. If neither side gives a damn, then how do we expect anything to be accomplished?
 The expats in the story had every right to enjoy themselves and go to clandestine speakeasys and parties; living in Afghanistan would be no picnic. But this story is no more different than that of NGO workers and young people who jet off to some exotic location to teach English or ‘help the poor.’ I believe in international work; I believe in NGOs. I believe that it would have been OK for the US to stay in Afghanistan post-invasion if it had really tried to engage with the people, with the Taliban, and properly used the $104 billion meant to rebuild–hell, build–the country. I believe that people have good intentions in these things. But in the end, it’s also all about us. It’s all about our perception of ourselves as do-gooders, as helpers. We stay a while, things seem peachy, and then we leave. We build people a house, but do the people have the means to upkeep that house, pay for the running water, the electricity? We teach English, but do those kids have the means to actually go out and use it? Did we make the people of Afghanistan hate the West a little less? Probably not.
The US might be worried about leaving Afghanistan in light of IS and Iraq, but that isn’t going to stop us from getting the hell home. If the Taliban starts up again, or IS somehow manages to puddle-jump Shiite Iran and get to Afghanistan, well, Obama will probably just shower down some rockets and hope that killing people will do the trick. Even if all members of an insurgent Quick-fix solutions to concrete problems seems to have been the answer in past diplomacy, although there are signs of change, at least in the academic world. War does not solve our problems; killing ideologies does.

Links

1. http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/last-tango-in-kabul-20140818?page=2

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Who cares about Afghanistan?

  1. Unfortunately and contrary to the Rolling Stone article’s assertion, war does in fact solve many problems that can’t be solved in other ways, such as how one human society obtains a settlement it wants against intractable opposition from another human group. If war didn’t solve any problems, then no wars would be fought.

    There are plenty of reasons to question the wisdom of U.S. policy in Afghanistan. I agree our campaign there hasn’t helped either the Afghanis or U.S. security, or been worth its massive costs. But I doubt the U.S. can “fix” or “rebuild” this country, a task which its own citizens will have to agree to undertake in priority over their internal conflicts. The latter long predate Western interference (cf Britain’s Durand in the 19th century), and will likely continue after the West no longer involves itself there.

    1. I do agree with you. The point of my article was that people have to want something in order to achieve it–hence the Afghans cannot make their country “better” if they don’t want to or don’t try, and it takes more than just ousting one dictator/ruler or throwing some bombs. I am against war, although I would agree that in some situations it may be the only way to solve a problem–take WWII for example. Hitler wanted to take over the world, which other countries didn’t want (obviously!) and i don’t think “talking him out of it” would have worked in that case. I just think the USA’s actions in Iraq and Afghanistan were just wrong.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s